
SPECIAL GUEST POST FROM DAN CHRISTENSEN
The application deadline is a week away. You have 40 resumes, several promising candidates, and a committee ready to start screening.
Before you build the interview list, ask one more question: Who would we want to talk to if we were starting from scratch?
You might think of an assistant who has been doing much of the recruiting at a nearby college. Or a head coach whose athletes stick around even though the program has fewer resources than its competitors. Maybe it’s someone an opposing coach has mentioned more than once.
If those names come to mind only after you’ve started interviews, you’ve maybe missed a chance to bring them into the conversation.
Give good candidates a reason to take a look
A coach can be happy in their current job and still be open to the right opportunity. They may never see your posting. Even if they do, a job description may tell them very little about why the move would make sense.
That’s where a personal invitation helps. Tell the coach what caught your attention and why it matters for this particular program.
“We’re looking for someone who can grow our roster and give those athletes a reason to stay. I’ve heard good things about how you’ve approached both at your current school. Would you be open to a brief conversation about what we’re building here?”
Be candid about the opportunity. If the position comes with a second campus assignment or limited assistant support, say so. The coach can make a better decision when they understand the job, and you can spend your time on people who are interested in the role you can actually offer.
Put someone in charge of outreach
Most athletic directors already have a full calendar when a coach leaves. If outreach is everybody’s responsibility, it can quickly become the thing nobody gets to.
Before the posting goes live, agree on the two or three things the next coach needs to do well. Then give one person responsibility for building a short list and making the first calls. Ask trusted contacts specific questions: “Who’s good at recruiting students who thrive at a school like ours?” will probably get you further than “Do you know any good coaches?”
Keep the outreach personal and discreet, and follow your institution’s hiring process. An invitation gives someone a reason to explore the position; every candidate still earns their place in the process against the same criteria.
Keep the door open in both directions
The strongest candidate may be the first person who applies. They may be an assistant ready for a first head coaching job, a coach between positions, or someone you had to call twice before they were willing to learn more. How they entered the pool tells you very little about how they’ll lead the program.
That’s why outreach and application review should happen alongside each other. The point of making calls is to give the committee more people worth comparing while it can still do something about it.
We expect our coaches to know who they want to recruit and why. Before your next posting goes live, take 20 minutes with your committee and ask: Who would we regret never calling?
Then make those calls while there’s still time for someone to say yes.
Dan Christensen is the Director of Collegiate Consulting for Bechler Leadership. Founded by Jamy Bechler in 2018, Bechler Leadership helps schools, athletic departments, and organizations build stronger cultures and maximize their potential. In the last three years, they’ve worked on 70+ searches, specializing in meeting the needs of “smaller” colleges. Dan can be reached at dan@bechlerleadership.com.