Jamy Bechler

Providing Insights on Leadership and Success. Coach Bechler is a John Maxwell Leadership Team Member.

  • Home
  • About
  • Store
  • Blog
  • SEARCH FIRM
  • Podcast
  • Media
  • Resources
  • Speaking
  • Training

Oct 21 2026

When the Wrong Coach Becomes Everyone’s Problem

SPECIAL GUEST POST FROM DAN CHRISTENSEN 

The search committee finishes its work. The announcement goes out. The new coach gets to work.

But the consequences of that decision are just beginning.

Over the next several years, admissions will work with that coach’s recruits. Faculty will teach their athletes. Athletic trainers will navigate their communication habits. Other coaches will share facilities, resources, and expectations with them.

And the athletic director will discover how much attention the program requires.

For smaller colleges, a coaching hire reaches well beyond one team. That should change how we evaluate candidates.

A full roster can hide an unhealthy program

It is easy to recognize a recruiting problem when a team falls well short of its roster goal.

The harder problem to spot is a coach who brings in enough athletes every fall but struggles to keep them.

The roster looks healthy on opening day. By spring, several athletes are looking to transfer, others have quit, and the coach is recruiting another large class to replace them.

Some turnover is unavoidable. But repeatedly replacing dissatisfied athletes is a different challenge from building a program students want to remain part of.

At a tuition-dependent institution, those departures can affect enrollment and revenue. They also create questions that deserve attention: Were recruits given an accurate picture of the experience? Did they feel supported? Were expectations clear?

A recruiting total tells you how many students arrived. It takes more investigation to understand what happened after they enrolled.

During a search, ask candidates to explain both.

Every hire creates work for someone

A coach who communicates clearly, handles conflict appropriately, and follows through on responsibilities makes the department easier to lead.

A coach who struggles in those areas creates work that lands on someone else’s desk.

The athletic director mediates another disagreement. Admissions sorts through promises it never approved. An assistant coach repairs relationships with frustrated athletes. A trainer spends extra time trying to establish basic communication.

Each situation may seem manageable on its own. Together, they can consume hours that other employees need for their own responsibilities.

There is an opportunity cost here, too. Time spent repeatedly addressing preventable problems is time unavailable for fundraising, staff development, campus partnerships, or supporting other programs.

Every new coach will need guidance. The search should help you distinguish between someone who needs support learning your institution and someone whose habits will require ongoing intervention.

The next search inherits the damage

Replacing an unsuccessful coach does not automatically reset a program.

The next coach may inherit a depleted roster, skeptical recruits, frustrated alumni, and returning athletes who have heard promises before.

That person’s first season may involve rebuilding trust before meaningful competitive progress is possible.

This is one reason the cost of a poor hire can extend beyond the coach’s employment. The institution may still be working through its effects after a replacement arrives.

It also means patience matters when evaluating the next coach. A program that took years to deteriorate may need more than one recruiting cycle to recover.

Ask for evidence of the everyday work

Most candidates can describe the culture they want to build. Search committees need to understand the habits behind that description.

Ask questions that move beyond philosophy:

  • Recruiting: How do you track prospects, involve admissions, and adjust when commitments fall through?
  • Retention: When athletes have left your program, what did you learn and change?
  • Accountability: Describe a time you held a productive player to a standard that carried a competitive cost.
  • Collaboration: How have you handled disagreement with athletic training staff or another campus office?
  • Organization: What systems keep communication, eligibility responsibilities, and administrative deadlines from slipping?

Then use references to explore those same areas. Someone who worked alongside the candidate may offer a different perspective from someone who supervised their win-loss record.

The institution has responsibilities here as well. Candidates need an honest understanding of roster expectations, available resources, workload, and support. Even a capable coach can struggle when hired into an opportunity that was inaccurately presented.

The goal is to make a decision grounded in how the person actually works—and whether that approach fits the job you need done.

Your next coach will shape an experience for student-athletes and a working environment for colleagues across campus.

Build a search that takes all of them into account.


 

Dan Christensen is the Director of Collegiate Consulting for Bechler Leadership. Founded by Jamy Bechler in 2018, Bechler Leadership helps schools, athletic departments, and organizations build stronger cultures and maximize their potential. In the last three years, they’ve worked on 70+ searches, specializing in meeting the needs of “smaller” colleges. Dan can be reached at dan@bechlerleadership.com.

You May Also Like ...

Written by Jamy Bechler · Categorized: Business, Job Search · Tagged: Admissions, Athletic Search, Bechler Enterprises, bechler leadership, College consulting, College Recruiting, Dan Christensen, Enrollment, Executive REcruiting, Jamy Bechler, Job Search, recruiting, Roster Management

Featured Blog Posts

  • 15 Ways Athletic Directors Can Show Gratitude
  • Bechler Shares Tale of Last-Minute Delivery
  • That Time My Wife Got Her Way … and I Was Glad
  • Who’s Missing From Your Coaching Search
  • Don’t Let a Good Interview Answer End the Conversation
  • When the Wrong Coach Becomes Everyone’s Problem
  • Brother’s Keeper
  • What Frustrates Coaches Most During a Search?
  • Making Your Bed
  • How Smaller Colleges Can Land Great Coaches

Blog Categories

  • Business
  • Job Search
  • Leadership
  • News
  • Personal Growth
  • Podcast Episodes
  • Sports
  • Teams & Organizations

Sign Up For Leadership Insights

Join Thousands Of Others Who Follow Jamy On These Platforms:

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Copyright © 2026 · Jamy Bechler · Providing Insights on Leadership and Success · site design: red letter design